The Columbia County Fair is canceled for this year, but you can still get “Fair Food” – like this Pepperoni or Meatball Heel at 225 Warren.
I grew up in an Italian-American family from the Bronx/Long Island, and I attended many San Genaro Festivals, but never have I seen this until I moved to Columbia County.
The pepperoni is slow-cooked for hours in a crock pot with homemade tomato sauce, then placed in (about) half of a loaf of hollowed-out Italian bread. Mozzarella cheese is melted on top and served hot. The pepperoni is stuffed into the bread when you pick it up.
It’s about eight to nine inches and too big for your mouth. Use forks and knives, if you’re fancy.
“Delicious!” says Scott Hotaling
By stuffing the pepperoni into the heel, at every moment, the bread stays crispy and firm. It’s REAL Italian bread – not supermarket doughy and soft, wrapped in plastic with a date stamp! No! This sesame seed bread is the bread that makes you take a number, and wait outside on Arthur Avenue. You wake up early on a Sunday morning for this bread. You go before Mass – before they sell out. You do not come home without this bread.
Usually, when you eat pepperoni, it’s one slice at a time on a piece of pizza – but this is multiple slices – in one bite! It’s almost too good, too gluttonous, to think that you can eat all this pepperoni at once! The pepperoni and sauce is spicy and sweet and the bread offers a soft, cushioning balance to soak up the flavors. You taste the sauce once the pepperoni is long gone – like a fond pepperoni memory.
Cheesy Expectations!
Set your cheese expectations accordingly. Just because there’s cheese at the beginning, does not mean that there’s cheese throughout, or at the end. One friend wished that there was more cheese.
I understand. However, wishing for more cheese – well, you could say that about almost any Italian meal!
At $12, this is a bargain! It’s a meal and a half. There are two/three versions – pepperoni, meatball or mixed. It’s only on Wednesdays, and maybe not forever. It’s not on the menu. You have to just KNOW.
If you go, tell them Trixie sent you!
Eaten with fresh, picked-from-the-garden salad, grown by The Naked Gardener Hudson.
Salad, because we’re healthy!
One of my favorite sandwiches and I never go to a fair without getting one! This recipe sounds awesome, I will definitely be in to try it!!!
Thank you! Thank you! I was wondering what I would do without my annual pepperoni sandwich from the fair. Years ago, you would be able to get them in several places in Hudson; also, spaghetti with pepperoni sauce (yummm!). But now that Hudson has gone chi-chi – they are a thing of the past, and the fair!
TN has nothing like it! Always miss this delicious sandwich at fair time! Yum!